April 24, 2005

Howard beats Harvard

In this year's moot court competitions Howard University beat Harvard in what was a first for Historically Black Colleges and Universities.

My man Bomani, himself a proud product of Clark Atlanta (where his old man Mack produced a generation or three of black political scientists), chimes in.

There is a pride in attending schools like Morehouse, Howard, Clark Atlanta and even Tennessee State that is as strong as fealty to a Christian denomination amongs Christians with a capital "C". I've been to more than a few black homecomings in my day, and there's nothing like being at the football game and hearing thousands upon thousands of black men and women singing their fight song at the top of their lungs.

But I think that we're making too much of kids' decision not to attend black schools.

The bottom line is that the comparison between Howard and Harvard is apt on one level--Howard is the best black law school, and Harvard is the best non-black law school. But on another level it makes much more sense to me to compare Howard as a law school in general to Wayne State. If a student tells me he got into Howard and Wayne State and wants to know which one he should choose? He should choose Howard. Better networking capabilities, better name recognition, probably a better learning experience. If he tells me he got into Howard and Harvard (or a Michigan)? He should choose Harvard.

What about at an undergrad level? I've told my peers that I'd be down with any decision my children make...almost. If they told me that they wanted to go to Mississippi State for undergrad? I'd withhold my loot. If they told me they wanted to go to Morris Brown? I'd do the same. Harvard vs. Howard? Probably a push.

Michigan vs. Howard?

Michigan.

Elite Eight fraternity or sorority vs. Non-black fraternity or sorority?

A Whole Nother Conversation.

Posted by at April 24, 2005 10:52 AM | TrackBack

I must say that I agree with you, Spence. My criticism, though, is with those people that automatically discount black schools on the basis of their negritude. I wouldn't argue that Clark was a better academic institution than Harvard, though I would say that the social environment is healthier, and that counts for a lot.

But the issue I posed wasn't just limited to black colleges, though that was the vessel I chose. It really boils down to something you mentioned--if you'll go to Mississippi State, Wayne State, East Carolina, or any schools on that level before going to some black schools, I've got serious questions for that person about white supremacy.

Posted by: Bomani at April 24, 2005 11:05 AM

Yeah, I'd have questions too.

It goes the other way as well. I had a student choose the University of Illinois at Chicago over Michigan. Powerful as hell. Smart as hell, and she wanted to be a political scientist. UIC doesn't even place graduates in higher education! I think she picked UIC because she was from Chicago and missed her parents...but damn.

Posted by: Lester Spence at April 24, 2005 12:16 PM

Good point LKS but if the prospective student is a first generation college student where do they seek help;sounds like a good bus. opourtunity (newsletter
tootsie

Posted by: tootsie at April 25, 2005 01:53 PM