September 20, 2004

Bi-Partisan Lunacy

On Monday, Joseph C. Phillips delivered this commentary on Tavis Smiley's NPR show:

http://www.npr.org/rundowns/segment.php?wfId=3927125

If you are "right of center," I'm sure you're screaming, turning purple, and swearing at those "left of center." So, after you catch your breath, consider this:

Clarence Thomas is said not to associate with anyone who has views left of center. This has been mentioned in a few articles about him, including some that show him in a good light.

So, while Mr. Phillips' friend was wrong, so is Clarence Thomas.


And what about Shelby Steele, who cast away his "friend," Glenn Loury?

http://phuakl.tripod.com/eTHOUGHT/Loury.html

A few days later, Steele phoned him. ''Where do you stand on race?'' Loury says Steele asked him. ''It's as if you're a racial loyalist here. I thought we all agreed.''

''No, Shelby and I didn't agree,'' Loury says now. ''I was always aware that, whatever I thought about race, I'm still black. Shelby's position. . . . '' Loury starts to laugh. ''I was about to say, Shelby's position was that we had to completely transcend race, though I can imagine saying those words, too. But my heart wasn't in them, whereas he really meant it. How could it have been otherwise? His mother was a white woman. His wife is a white woman. When he looked at his own children's racial identity and wondered about an oppressive world that would say to those children, 'Choose sides' -- a dilemma I'd never faced -- Shelby's angle of vision was really quite different from my own. So in all honesty, it was I who betrayed him, not he who betrayed me.'' The two men have not spoken since that conversation. (Steele declined to be interviewed for this article.)


No, two wrongs don't make a right. But don't whine about it only when it happens to you.

Posted by at September 20, 2004 06:25 PM | TrackBack

I haven't heard about Clarence Thomas's associations. Folks do have freedom of association in USA. However, dissing your close friends because of their political views - be it Joseph Phillip's friend or Shelby Steele's treatment of Glenn Loury - is unloyal and foul.

Your last sentence goes both ways though.

Posted by: molotov at September 21, 2004 11:54 PM